Bulugh al-Maram — Hadith #53141

From Safia bint Shayba, he said: "Allah sends blessings on him and give him peace - gave some of his wives a handful of barley." Narrated Al-Bukhari 1.1. - Mursal. Al-Bukhari (5172), through Al-Saori, from Mansour bin Safiya, is also described with it, under the authority of Umm Safia. I said: This is Mursal, Safia bint Shaybah, a tabee, who has no evidence, because multiple people have confirmed it, such as Ibn Sa'd and Ibn Hibban. and other. Trusted people, such as Ibn Mahdi, Waqi'i, Al-Fariabi, Ibn Abi Zaydah, and others, agreed to the hadith under the authority of Sufyan and did not go beyond "Safia bint Shaybah". Some weak, such as Yahya bin Al-Yaman and Mumil bin Ismail, disagree with them, narrated it from Al-Sauri, and they said in it: "Safia bint Shayba's authority, according to Aisha." And the best of those who have described it with references from Al-Sauri. Aisha” Abu Ahmed Al-Jubayri; narrated by Muhammad bin Abdullah, Ahmad (6/113), so he is faithful. Besides, in the authority of Al-Sauri, there are some words in his description, and Imam Ahmad even says: "He made many mistakes in the hadith of Sufyan." This is why he described by Al-Nasayy as "Al-Qubra" (4/140) and Ismail al-Qadi "Al-Naqat al-Zarf" (11/342) and Al-Barkani and Al-Daraqutni "9/238-239).